Welcome to Carmine's Italian Deli, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Jersey City at 165 Mallory Ave. This authentic Italian restaurant is not just a place to eat; it’s a culinary journey that embraces the rich flavors of Italy while satisfying your cravings for home-cooked meals. With a phone call away at +1 201-434-5155, you can dive into a world of vibrant tastes that transport you straight to an Italian kitchen.
Carmine's offers an impressive range of options, from refreshing cold salads like the Mozzarella Caprese and Antipasto Salad to indulgent hot sandwiches, such as the fan-favorite Chicken Parmigiana and the delicious Meatball Sandwich. Patrons rave about the intense flavors and freshness of their dishes. For instance, customer Boris T.N. had a memorable experience with his prosciutto mozzarella sun-dried tomato balsamic sandwich that brought him to tears—an ultimate testament to the quality served at Carmine’s.
The deli prides itself on more than just food. The welcoming ambiance paired with service that feels like family makes every visit special. As Helen Pham articulates, the delicious food and genuine hospitality keep customers returning year after year. Whether you're in for a quick bite or catering for a special event, Carmine’s ensures that each meal is prepared with utmost care and authenticity. Their catering services are particularly praised for their unmatched quality, elevating any gathering with exceptional Italian fare.
For homestyle cooking lovers, dishes like the Chicken Parmesan over Linguine and Eggplant over Pasta serve as reminders of nostalgic family dinners. Kevin Umanzor, a satisfied customer, emphasized that nothing on the menu comes from a microwave—each plate is genuine, hearty, and deeply satisfying.
From the moments filled with laughter shared over a delicious Chicken Cutlet on garlic bread to the local community feeling that Carmine fosters, this deli stands out for its commitment to quality and taste. With a mantra of cash-only simplicity, Carmine's makes every customer feel valued while enjoying authentic Italian dishes crafted from time-honored recipes.
If you’re craving a slice of Italy just around the corner, don’t miss out on the culinary delights waiting for you at Carmine's Italian Deli. It's not just a meal; it's an experience you’ll want to savor again and again.
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
2366 Poplar Dr, Medford, OR 97504, United States
3118 W Northwest Hwy, Dallas, TX 75220, United States
296 E 29th St, Loveland, CO 80538, United States
1003 W Patrick St, Frederick, MD 21702, United States
4325 Lien Rd, Madison, WI 53704, United States
Oscar Fernandez
22/10/2025
Original Italian deli with the plus that they also made homemade pastas and meals. Prices and portions are fair, but the taste of the sandwich was the golden factor. Very fresh and full of flavor. Definitely a place to come back.
Helen Pham
17/10/2025
I’ve been a fan of this Italian deli for years, and it never disappoints! The food is always fantastic—fresh, flavorful, and exactly what you’d expect from a top-notch deli. It’s been around for so long, and every single person I’ve referred has loved it as much as I do. The team there is so welcoming and helpful, no matter what time I visit. I especially appreciate their catering services—unmatched in both quality and service. If you’re looking for delicious food and great people, this is the place!
Boris T.N.
08/10/2025
I am new-ish to the neighborhood and I've always been meaning to come in, but my job works a little later and I've never been able to catch the restaurant during their hours. I came in yesterday and ordered a prosciutto mozzarella sun-dried tomato balsamic sandwich and I can tell you hands-down that I almost cried because it was so delicious. I went back to the counter and introduced myself and I met Carmine himself and he welcomed me to the neighborhood and said to come in anytime and then he'll take care of me and that he has anything I want in terms of home groceries. he asked if I liked lentil soup and he packed me a cup of soup to go. i'm coming back and I'm bringing all my friends. A class act and an example of what a great business should be!
Kevin Umanzor
02/10/2025
This was a very good place to come eat some authentic Italian. I ordered the chicken parmesan over linguine, it was definitely good. It's home cooking all the way. Nothing microwave or box food at all. My mother ordered the eggplant over pasta, and that was delicious. Never knew eggplant could taste so good. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone wanting authentic Italian. I love home cooking, and that is exactly what you get here. The portions is also impressive. Couldn't finish it all because I got full. The price is well worth it here. It is not expensive at all, especially considering the quantity and quality of their food.
Blake Lew-Merwin
30/07/2025
So incredibly fire. Perfect after hitting the courts in Lincoln Park. I got the chicken cutlet, mozz, RRP and balsamic. Listen to the guy — it on the garlic bread, you will thank me later. Everything here is high quality, from the mozz to the oil to the meats. Sometimes chicken cutlets can be bad but you can tell they obviously make these very fresh and in house. I didn’t get to take a photo of it, but here’s a pic of the Italian sub which was equally as good. CASH ONLY!
Katherine
22/07/2025
Excellent deli. The stuffed peppers and sandwiches were delicious. Very limited seating and no bathrooms. The foodbis worth a visit and the staff was great.
Saxokobe
18/07/2025
When I first moved to US 3 years ago Carmine Deli was the first Deli that i have visited and I was total blown away by it. It's not your Michelin Star restaurant but it is definitely your neighborhood go to place that has been with the community for a long time. The vibe and the food are 100% worth your visit.
Jackson Farley
07/07/2025
Carmine’s will not disappoint. Promise. Classic Italian deli. Cash only. We got the grilled chicken Caesar wrap and the chicken cutlet/moz/long pepper cold sandwich. Both were 10/10 no notes.